Is hanging your hammock or hitting the ground the best choice? Winter camping tests more than gear—it tests grit. In this Winter Camping Shelter Showdown, we pit hammocks against ground shelters to see which setup keeps you warmer, drier, and saner when the cold closes in! The Winter Camping Shelter Showdown is not just about preference; it’s about survival and comfort.
Winter camping isn’t just about braving the cold. It’s about claiming a rare kind of solitude. Winter is a natural filter, keeping out the casual dog walkers and the curious wanderers who crowd trails in warmer months. Even those with bad intentions tend to vanish when temperatures drop below comfort. Also, if you hate bugs, snakes, and crowds, you may be a closet winter camper.
The wilderness remains quieter and cleaner, welcoming the more strong-willed and adventurous. It takes a certain mindset to see beauty in frozen mornings and the secrets winter camping reveals. Crisp silence, untouched snow, and the satisfaction of knowing you’ve stepped into a world most will never dare to enter.
Advertisement — Continue Reading Below
Indeed, this is where the Winter Camping Shelter Showdown showcases its importance.
Sleeping in the woods is what keeps a great deal of people in the three-season category. Growing up in the southwest, winter camping wasn’t too cold an event, unless we were at a high elevation. However, in the northeast, no elevation is required for it to be 20 degrees (Fahrenheit). And this is on a typical winter day full of clear blue skies and sunshine. This variation emphasizes the stakes in winter shelters.
Advertisement — Continue Reading Below
Winter Camping Precautions
When the temperature drops, sleep becomes survival. In winter camping, precautions matter as much as gear. Always insulate beneath you. Cold creeps up from the ground (by conduction and convection) faster than it does from the air.
Layer wisely with a dry base layer and a thermal mid-layer. On top, use a breathable shell to keep sweat from freezing. Vent your shelter to prevent condensation, which can soak insulation and steal warmth. Keep water and footwear inside the shelter to stop them from freezing solid overnight.
And never ignore your head and feet. Extra insulation there can mean the difference between rest and misery. Winter nights punish the careless, but a few smart steps turn them into manageable challenges!
Advertisement — Continue Reading Below
Hanging In The Winter
People who prefer to sleep in a hammock are called hangers. I was a hanger for about 10 years before I switched it up. I only go back to hanging out in humid, hot places like the southern USA or the jungles of South America and Southeast Asia.
However, I’ve had my share of cold nights in a hammock. I made all the big mistakes, like not using an insulating pad underneath and using a net-style hammock. Eventually, I moved to the ground and found my home. Less gear weight and less convection (wind) to deal with when ground sleeping.
Advertisement — Continue Reading Below
I have a handful of friends who are hangers to the bone. No matter the weather, you’ll find them swaying in the breeze. In winter, they tote a lot of weight with the many pieces of gear needed to hang a hammock. Not to mention the amount of extra gear needed to keep themselves warm. All of this highlights the choices and strategies in a Winter Camping Shelter Showdown.
Winter Hammock Sleep System Essentials
- Top quilt: traps heat from above, lighter than a sleeping bag.
- Bottom quilt: insulates beneath, blocks cold air from stealing warmth.
- Pad inside hammock: adds insulation and structure, especially under hips and shoulders.
- Bottom sleeve or underquilt protector: shields against rain splash, snow drift, and wind.
- Suspension system: strong straps and hardware to secure the hammock safely.
- Tarp overhead: creates a roof against snow, rain, and wind.
That’s a lot of stuff. Weight, setup, and money are significant factors when hanging in the winter. The truth is, most of them still have a cold night.
Advertisement — Continue Reading Below
Winter Ground Shelter
Sleeping on the ground is a natural way to camp. It always has been. Like usual, you’ll need something to sleep on, under, and inside of. A backpacker’s trick for staying warm in the cold is to wear your layers while sleeping. This camp hack isn’t anything new. Old-timey mountain men did this, too.
Ground sleeping in winter shines because it’s lighter, simpler, and more universal than hammock camping. You don’t need specialized quilts or suspension systems—just a pad, covering, and overhead shelter. The gear is familiar, easy to replace, and works on any terrain, whether you’re above treeline or in a forest with poor tree spacing.
A tent or tarp also offers stability against wind and snow, and makes it possible to share warmth with others. In emergencies, ground systems adapt quickly—you can improvise. For winter campers, the appeal is clear: less gear, less fuss, and a straightforward path to warmth and rest, which often wins in the Winter Camping Shelter Showdown.
Advertisement — Continue Reading Below
Winter Ground Sleeping Essentials
- Closed-cell foam pad: insulates against frozen ground and blocks heat loss.
- Tarp or tent overhead: shields against wind, snow, and rain.
- Bivy sack: adds a protective shell, traps warmth, and keeps insulation dry.
- Blanket, sleeping bag, or quilt: provides core warmth inside the bivy.
Ground sleeping is lighter and more cost-efficient. It’s simple. And when the cold is biting, a faster shelter is better than one that takes more dexterity in cold fingers and longer setup times!
Read the full article here
